Opinion

Aaron Glenn’s Josh Allen Complaint Is Really About Whose Quarterback It Is

Aaron Glenn said what every fan of a non-Buffalo quarterback has muttered at a TV. CBS cameras caught the Jets coach at halftime telling Ron Torbert’s crew that if that was Josh Allen, every flag on the field would be thrown.

The play: Geno Smith slipped out of the pocket, set his feet, and got hit the instant the ball left his hand. Terrel Bernard got his chest, rookie T.J. Parker dove at his knees. No flag. Smith went into the concussion protocol, and that is all anyone outside the Jets building should say about his condition.

Now the rules part, and I’m not going to pretend Glenn is wrong here. Awful Announcing lays out that leaving the pocket strips some protections, but they come back once a passer stops behind the line and resets to throw, which Smith had done by the time both defenders arrived. On that reading the no-call is very hard to defend. Gene Steratore, on the CBS broadcast, still told viewers the crew got it right. Sure he did.

The rulebook points one way, and the optics point another. My read: the league has spent about two decades wrapping its quarterbacks in bubble wrap, and the wrap has never been evenly distributed. Glenn’s point is that Allen, signed through 2030, would have gotten the whistle. Smith took the hit, and the flag stayed in the pocket.

Whether the hit was definitively illegal is a call for people with a replay and a rulebook. What I can see is a coach looking at an official and naming the one quarterback he figured would have gotten the flag. Hard to argue he picked the wrong name.

Raiders fans have a particular view of this one. Smith was their quarterback last season before Las Vegas sent him back to the Jets in March, so they know the guy getting hit here. Every fan base wants the same protection for its guy, and every fan base suspects somebody else’s guy gets it first.

The no-call stands, and so does the suspicion.

Related Stories